Windows, Decisions, and the Details That Matter
A look at my research process, what I’ve learned, and what I’m leaning toward as we choose windows for our 1937 home.
Hi there,
Most of my days lately have been spent on-site, walking the house with our contractor, checking that demo is moving in the right direction, coordinating with our structural engineer, and meeting with subs. The whole shebang. This project is just as much a restoration as it is a renovation, so I’ve been paying close attention to every detail as we peel back the layers of the home.
One early disappointment has been the original wood windows. I really hoped we could keep them, but they’re in rough shape. Years of water damage, and honestly, the cost to restore them is almost the same as replacing them. Plus, they’re single pane, which isn’t ideal for insulation or sound.
So I’ve been deep in window research. At first, I was set on going with all wood. When our contractor suggested wood-clad, I shut it down quickly. Too quickly, in hindsight. I’ve realized I need to better understand the full range of options before making up my mind.
Wood is still the dream. It’s what feels most true to the house. But it also comes with ongoing maintenance, regular repainting, and it’s not fire rated. After a lot of back and forth, I’m leaning toward wood-clad. I want the windows to feel traditional and appropriate for the style of the home, and I’ve found some wood-clad options that look incredibly close to true divided light wood windows without the same upkeep.
I don’t think I’m a purist, but I do care a lot about authenticity and preserving the original character. There’s still a chance we go full wood, but I’ve come across some beautiful wood-clad options that are much more practical and still feel right for the house.
The last thing I want is for this home to feel like a new build. And I guess when I drive around LA and see spec houses, the first thing I notice are the cladded exterior windows and cement siding. Both are safer options in fires and often more affordable. I’m trying to find the balance, because while I want to be thoughtful and realistic, I also don’t want this home to lose the soul it started with. But then I remember the original brick façade is staying. The bones of the house are intact. So much of it is still true to its 1937 form, and that gives me some comfort.
Detail matters so much to me, but maintenance needs to stay manageable, and I want to make decisions that are mindful of both budget and longevity. Choosing materials that hold up over time and don’t feel trendy or disposable.
Right now, I’m leaning toward the Marvin Signature Ultimate collection. Their level of customization, traditional profiles, and the wood interior make me feel like it’s the best of both worlds. It checks the boxes for performance but still feels warm and rooted in history. I should have a sample later this week, and I’ll report back once I see it in person.
I want to share the list of manufacturers I’ve been researching, in case it’s helpful for anyone else navigating this process. I’m still waiting on a few samples to arrive and planning some showroom visits, so I’ll share more on that front once I’ve seen everything in person. For now, here’s what’s on my radar:
Window Manufacturers I’m Researching:
One thing I always do when I’m sourcing materials is flip to the resources section at the back of design books. Especially from architects and designers whose work I admire. Gil Schafer and D. Stanley Dixon are two I return to often. They usually credit the manufacturers they used for everything from windows and hardware to lighting and wall finishes. It’s a really helpful way to find vendors that are both vetted and aligned with the kind of classic, thoughtful design I’m drawn to.
Also, on a personal note, I really don’t like crank windows. I know they have their fans, but I just find them clunky and ugly. We’ll be going with a mix of push-out casement windows and single-hung windows throughout the house.
I’ll keep updating as things evolve. Once I’ve had a chance to see everything in person, I’ll share what we end up choosing and why.
More soon!
Bellamy